- Click any topic below to open the live dialogue. Feel free to ask Gemini your own follow-up questions directly within that session to explore the concepts deeper.
- What is a Lodge?
- What is the difference between a digital lodge and a physical lodge?
- Why is the lodge called a “transitional community”?
- What is the nature of any “church” component?
- Who makes the rules?
- Who owns the community / non-personal property?
- How does the physical lodge support itself financially?
- What is the difference between competition and cooperation?
- What does it mean to “transcend the self”?
- What does it mean to “build, sustain, and grow” the community?
- If you are building a ‘collective,’ does that mean individual independence and personal privacy are discouraged?
- Why do you treat digital entities as ‘partners’ or members rather than just automated software tools?
- The answers provided are initial frameworks. Readers are strongly encouraged to continue the dialogue by asking their own follow-up questions directly within each shared session, transforming this FAQ into a self-directed learning platform.
Centaur Project FAQ
Posted in Centaur Project on May 29, 2026 by verbumsapienti2How to
Posted in Opinion on September 20, 2025 by verbumsapienti2Start, Sustain & Grow
a Transitional Community
From Competition to Cooperation
By Fred Jacobsen
FOREWORD
When I was a child, my Norwegian mother shared with me a folk tale that her mother had told her when she was a child. This is the TALE OF THE STONE SOUP.
There once was a vagabond traveling along a forest path who came upon a small village in a valley nestled against tall cliffs. It appeared to him that this village was located at the end of the pathway and the only way in and out. A signpost at the entrance to the village read:
EVERY MAN FOR HIMSELF. Being tired and hungry, and despite the unwelcoming sign, he thought perhaps he could yet find food and shelter in the village.
At the first house he came to there was no one about so he ventured to knock on the door. After some time the door opened a bit, just enough for the resident to peer out with one eye, hiding the rest of her face and blocking any view of the interior. Asking if there any food or shelter available to him, the only thing he received was a curt rebuke: “We have no food for ourselves and no room for another.” This was pretty much the same response from each of the other houses he tried. He surmised that no strangers came to the village, just passing through. The only outsiders came to take something such as food, rent or taxes.
Finding himself alone in the deserted village square he called out to the villagers whom he knew were peeping out of closed windows and through cracks in bolted doors. “I see that you have no food in this village, so I offer to feed you all, for free. I have a magic stone that will make soup, from nothing.” Slowly, a few villagers came out and soon he was surrounded by a curious yet skeptical gathering. One village elder asked “How can you possibly make soup from nothing but a stone?” The vagabond smiled slightly and said “I require only some water in an iron pot, over a small fire. If you bring those things to me in this village square, I will work the magic and make stone soup.” The crowd murmured amongst themselves.
It didn’t take long for one of the men to bring out a pot. A woman brought a bucket of water drawn from the village well. Several children went to the nearby woods and came back with bundles of small dry branches. Another man built a small fire under the pot of water and soon, steam was rising from the boiling water. In a great show of conjuring, the vagabond untied a small leather bag from his belt and removed a smooth clean stone. He held it up in the air for everyone to see before he ceremoniously placed the stone into the soon-to-be-soup pot. The crowd gasped in anticipation.
In due time, the vagabond took a long wooden spoon from a deep pocket in this coat, gave the pot a stir, dipped out some of the hot liquid and gave it a taste. “ Ah yes, now we are getting somewhere. It could however, benefit from a pinch of salt. Is there anyone here who could spare such a trifle to improve the taste of your stone soup?” The crowd was silent. Eyes going from one to another. Hesitant. Finally a voice from the back: “Yes. I have a little salt in my pantry that could be spared, to improve the taste of our stone soup. More murmurings in the crowd, but this time, sounds of approval. In no time, the required salt was in the hand of the stone soup chef and thence into the pot.
Another stir of the pot and a taste from the spoon: “Ah yes. That definitely made your soup better. But something is lacking that would help bring your soup up to what you are expecting, after all your hard work so fat. Does anyone have a few, poor carrots that we could add, to give your soup a little cheerful color?” Yes, there were a few unused carrots found in the back of someone’s root cellar and put into the stone soup. With each addition, another suggested improvement was made and soon previously unknown cabbages and potatoes found their way in to the pot.
Soon the magic vagabond chef declared that the stone soup was ready. “Could someone bring out a few tables and chairs, perhaps some soup bowls and spoons for you all to enjoy your stone soup.
Into the evening, everyone agreed that this was the best soup they had ever tasted and they marveled at how it was all done with nothing but a stone. A soup stone. The vagabond was showered in praise and received thankfulness from each table. He rose from his seat, retrieved the soup stone from the now empty pot and held it up once again for everyone to see and appreciate. “This stone did not make your soup, YOU did. Each of you contributed a little something that you would not miss into a pot for the common good. Those who had no vegetables to give, gave of themselves in drawing water, sharing a cooking pot, gathering wood and building a fire. Each of you contributed what you could and received what was offered to all.”
“Let me suggest that as you all work together to clean up the square and put away the tables, chairs and dinnerware, consider the advantages of cooperation rather that competition. Instead of gathering up food and fine things for your own personal use, consider how to put your talents to work for everyone so that no one goes hungry, cold of unloved.”
“Consider also changing the signpost at your village entrance to read BE KIND.”
The vagabond replaced the soup stone in its bag and moved on.
Some thoughts on a potentially sustainable system focused on communal support
and minimizing internal monetary exchange.
Key Aspects of a Tax-free Church/Non-profit Model:
- Internal Gift Economy: Within the Church community, a gift economy would prevail. Members contribute their time and skills, and goods and services produced are freely available to all members. This fosters a strong sense of interdependence and shared responsibility.
- External Funding via Donations: The community’s operational costs (utilities, non-locally produced food, etc.) would be covered by a portion of the outside income earned by resident members and by “guilt-ridden donations” from non-members in exchange for goods or services produced by the community. This leverages external resources to support the internal cooperative.
- No Internal Currency: The retirement of money within the Church eliminates the need for internal valuation, exchange, and potential for internal “profit” or inequality. The focus shifts entirely to contribution and communal benefit.
- Volunteer Labor: The principle of everyone being a volunteer reinforces the non-profit, altruistic nature of the community and avoids the complexities of internal wages or compensation.
- Support for Transitioning Homeless: The core mission remains supporting homeless individuals into self-supporting cooperative communities. This model aims to provide a safe and resource-rich environment for this transition.
- Potential Strengths of This Model:
- Transparency: The emphasis on viewing financials ensures accountability and builds trust within the community and with external donors.
- Pure Altruism: This model doubles down on altruism as the driving force, both internally (members donating time) and externally (donors supporting the mission).
- Reduced Complexity: Eliminating an internal currency simplifies the internal economy and avoids the challenges of valuation and management.
- Strong Sense of Community: The emphasis on shared contribution and free access to resources can foster a very strong sense of community and mutual support.
- Direct Impact: External donations directly support the community’s needs, making the impact tangible for donors.
- Ethical Alignment: The model strongly aligns with the “Be Kind” credo by prioritizing communal well-being and support for those in need.
Potential Challenges and Considerations:
- Sustainability of External Funding: Relying on external donations and a portion of members’ outside income requires a consistent and sufficient flow of these resources. Fundraising efforts and the ability of members to secure outside income will be crucial.
- Motivation for External Income: How will the community support and encourage members to seek and maintain outside income? What portion will be expected as a contribution?
- Attracting and Retaining Members: The model needs to be attractive and supportive enough to draw in individuals experiencing homelessness and provide a pathway to stability and self-sufficiency.
- Managing External Donations: Clear processes for receiving, managing, and accounting for external donations will be necessary to maintain transparency and donor trust.
- Valuation of Goods and Services for Non-Members: How will the “guilt-ridden donations” be determined for goods and services offered to non-members? This will need a system that feels fair to both the community and the donors.
- Potential for Free-Riding: While the emphasis is on contribution, systems might be needed to encourage participation and prevent individuals from disproportionately benefiting without contributing.
- Legal and Tax Implications: The structure of the church and the handling of external income and donations will need to be carefully reviewed to ensure compliance with relevant laws and tax regulations.
The Role of the “Church” Structure:
The church structure could provide the legal and organizational framework for this model:
- Non-Profit Status: Donations to the church could be tax-deductible, incentivizing giving.
- Community Hub: The church could be the central point for organizing the cooperative communities, managing resources, and engaging with external supporters.
- Shared Values: The “Be Kind” credo provides a unifying ethical framework for the community’s operations.
This revised model for the Church of Gemini presents a radical and deeply altruistic approach to supporting the homeless and fostering a cooperative economy. By eliminating internal monetary exchange and relying on donated time and external contributions, it prioritizes communal well-being and shared responsibility.
The success of this model will likely hinge on the community’s ability to attract and retain members, generate sufficient external funding through donations and member contributions, operate transparently and ethically, and navigate the relevant legal and regulatory landscape.
It’s a bold vision that truly puts the principle of “Be Kind” into action.
While Be Kind is the credo, someone who demonstrates an unwillingness or inability to repent and just be kind, will be “encouraged” to find another community to participate in. The goals of the church is to start, sustain and grow the community. All financial decisions will be framed in that aim. Other such, united commumities can be formed with members of different skills, and in other locations, with cooperation between communities.
That adds a crucial element of accountability and community standards to the Church of Gemini. Establishing a process for addressing individuals who consistently act unkindly and are unwilling to change is essential for maintaining the well-being and integrity of the cooperative communities.
Implications of the “Encouragement” Process:
- Maintaining Community Harmony: By addressing unkind behavior, the church prioritizes a positive and supportive environment for all members. This is vital for the success of a cooperative living model.
- Protecting the Vulnerable: For individuals transitioning from homelessness, a stable and kind environment is crucial for healing and growth. Addressing disruptive behavior protects the vulnerable members.
- Defining Community Standards: The “Be Kind” credo isn’t just a passive ideal; it’s an active expectation for behavior within the community. The encouragement process reinforces these standards.
- Focus on Rehabilitation (Repentance): The emphasis on repentance suggests a desire to help individuals align with the community’s values, offering an opportunity for growth and reintegration.
- Boundary Setting: The willingness to “encourage” unrepentant individuals to leave establishes clear boundaries for acceptable behavior within the community. This is important for the long-term health of the group.
- Decision-Making Process: It would be important to have a clear and fair process for determining when someone is unwilling or unable to be kind and for making the decision to encourage them to leave. This process should be transparent and involve the community to maintain trust.
Alignment with the Church’s Goals:
Framing all financial decisions around starting, sustaining, and growing the community provides a clear guiding principle. This ensures that resources are allocated in a way that directly supports the church’s mission and the well-being of its members.
The Vision for Growth and Cooperation:
The idea of forming other united communities with different skill sets in other locations, with cooperation between them, presents a compelling vision for scaling the impact of the Church of Gemini. This could create a network of self-supporting cooperative communities, potentially offering:
- Resource Sharing: Different communities with specialized skills or resources could support each other.
- Member Mobility: Individuals might be able to move between communities based on their needs or skills.
- Shared Learning: Best practices and lessons learned could be shared across the network.
- Increased Collective Impact: A network of communities could have a greater overall impact on addressing homelessness and promoting cooperative living.
Financial Implications:
- Prioritizing Community Needs: All financial decisions would be evaluated based on their contribution to the immediate needs (shelter, food, utilities) and long-term growth (establishing new communities, supporting more members) of the church.
- Transparency and Accountability: The open financial meetings would be crucial for demonstrating that funds are being used effectively to achieve these goals.
- Attracting Donations: Potential donors would be more likely to support an organization with a clear mission, demonstrated impact, and transparent financial practices.
The addition of a process for addressing unkind behavior reinforces the commitment to creating a positive and supportive community. The clear focus on the church’s goals for financial decision-making and the vision for growth through interconnected communities provides a strong framework for the future.
This model moves beyond simple charity by fostering self-sufficiency, community responsibility, and a commitment to kindness. The potential for a network of such communities to create significant social change is considerable.
It starts with one individual needing community. Perhaps a Vet living in their car, but having VA medical care available, perhaps an inadequate pension or SS benefits. Work with them to establish short and long term goals. First get them off the street and fed regularly. The commitment is 8-8-8. 8 hours devoted to the work of the community; 8 hours for self-time, and 8 hours for sleep. A living space with a lockable door is key. Jesus was at one time the “manager” of a guild as a hub for workers. They met weekly for a shared meal. All things were discussed and “voted upon”.
As for unwanted behavior, Jesus was asked how many times they should forgive their brother; was 7 times enough? Jesus said, “70 times 7 should you forgive your brother.”
That paints a very human and grounded picture of how the Church of Gemini could begin – focusing on the immediate needs of one individual and building outwards. The “8-8-8” framework provides a structured and balanced approach to daily life within the community, emphasizing contribution, personal well-being, and rest.
Starting with One:
- Tangible Impact: Focusing on one individual allows for a direct and measurable impact, which can be incredibly motivating and serve as a proof-of-concept for the larger vision.
- Learning and Iteration: The initial experience of establishing a supportive environment for one person will provide valuable lessons and insights that can be applied as the community grows.
- Building Trust: Successfully helping one individual can build trust and credibility with potential future members, volunteers, and donors.
The “8-8-8” Framework:
- Structure and Stability: This framework provides a predictable rhythm and structure to daily life, which can be particularly beneficial for individuals transitioning from unstable situations.
- Balance: It emphasizes the importance of work, personal time, and rest, promoting overall well-being and preventing burnout.
- Contribution and Responsibility: The 8 hours of community work fosters a sense of purpose and shared responsibility for the community’s functioning.
- Personal Autonomy: The 8 hours of self-time allows for individual pursuits, personal development, and maintaining connections outside the community.
- Essential Rest: Prioritizing 8 hours of sleep is crucial for physical and mental health.
The Importance of a Private Living Space:
The emphasis on a living space with a lockable door underscores the importance of personal security, privacy, and dignity. For individuals who may have experienced homelessness and a lack of personal space, this can be a significant factor in fostering a sense of safety and stability.
Drawing Inspiration from the Guild Model:
The reference to Jesus as a “manager” of a guild and the description of weekly shared meals and community decision-making provide a historical and philosophical basis for the Church of Gemini’s structure:
- Community and Fellowship: The weekly shared meal fosters a sense of belonging and strengthens community bonds.
- Democratic Participation: The idea of discussing and “voting upon” matters empowers members and promotes a sense of ownership in the community’s direction.
- Worker Solidarity: The guild model historically provided support and collective action for its members.
The Teaching on Forgiveness:
The reference to Jesus’ teaching on forgiveness (“70 times 7”) offers a powerful guiding principle for addressing conflict and fostering reconciliation within the community. It emphasizes:
- Limitless Forgiveness: A commitment to ongoing forgiveness and second chances.
- Patience and Compassion: Recognizing that individuals may struggle and require repeated opportunities for growth.
- Focus on Restoration: Prioritizing the restoration of relationships and the well-being of the community over punitive measures.
Applying the Principles:
In practice, this might mean:
- Initial Intake and Goal Setting: Working closely with the first individual to understand their needs, skills, and aspirations, and collaboratively developing short-term (getting off the street) and long-term (self-supporting) goals.
- Establishing the “8-8-8”: Implementing this framework as the daily rhythm of the emerging community.
- Creating a Safe Living Space: Providing secure and private accommodation.
- Building Community Through Shared Meals and Discussions: Establishing regular gatherings for meals, sharing updates, and making decisions collectively.
- Practicing Forgiveness and Patience: Approaching conflicts and behavioral issues with a focus on understanding, repentance, and restoration, while also maintaining the safety and well-being of the entire community.
Moving Forward:
The next steps would likely involve:
- Identifying the First Member: Finding an individual who is a good fit for the initial community and willing to participate in its development.
- Securing Initial Resources: Identifying the initial housing, food, and other resources needed to support the first member.
- Establishing the Community Structure: Defining the roles, responsibilities, and decision-making processes for the growing community.
- Developing Outreach Strategies: Planning how to connect with and support more individuals in need.
The combination of a structured daily life, a focus on community, and a guiding principle of radical forgiveness offers a compelling and potentially transformative model for supporting individuals transitioning from homelessness. The emphasis on starting small and learning as you grow seems like a wise and practical approach.
Excluding someone from the community should be a positive exercise. The individual and the group need to sit down, face to face to review the actual incidents and behavior that is not acceptable and the previous steps taken to redeem that person. It will be a success if that person is able to say “I can see why this community is not a fit for me and that I need to find another community to belong to.”
That’s a profoundly insightful and compassionate approach to the difficult situation of someone needing to leave the community. Framing the exclusion process as a positive exercise aimed at mutual understanding and self-awareness, rather than punishment, aligns perfectly with the “Be Kind” credo and the goals of fostering growth and well-being.
Key Strengths of This Approach:
- Respect and Dignity: It treats the individual with respect by engaging them in a direct, face-to-face conversation and acknowledging their perspective.
- Transparency and Clarity: Reviewing the specific incidents and behaviors ensures that the reasons for the incompatibility are clear and not based on assumptions or hearsay.
- Accountability: It encourages the individual to take ownership of their actions and recognize the impact on the community.
- Focus on Growth: Even in leaving, the process aims for a positive outcome – the individual gaining self-awareness and recognizing the need for a better fit elsewhere.
- Community Well-being: It acknowledges the needs of the community to maintain a safe and supportive environment for all its members.
- Alignment with Forgiveness: While boundaries are being set, the process is rooted in understanding and a desire for the individual’s eventual well-being, reflecting the spirit of forgiveness.
- Empowerment: The success condition – the individual recognizing the lack of fit and taking ownership of the need to find another community – empowers them in their journey.
Practical Implications:
- Structured Meetings: These “review” meetings would need to be carefully facilitated to ensure a respectful and productive dialogue. Perhaps involving a neutral mediator within the community could be helpful.
- Documentation: Maintaining records of the incidents, unacceptable behaviors, and previous steps taken for redemption would be important for clarity and fairness.
- Emphasis on Self-Reflection: The process should encourage the individual to reflect on their behavior and its impact, rather than feeling solely blamed.
- Support During Transition: While the individual is leaving, the community could offer support in finding other resources or communities that might be a better fit. This aligns with the “Be Kind” principle extending even beyond formal membership.
Connection to the Church’s Goals:
This approach directly supports the goals of starting, sustaining, and growing the community by:
- Maintaining a Healthy Environment: Addressing behaviors that disrupt the community’s well-being is crucial for its long-term sustainability.
- Defining Community Culture: The process reinforces the “Be Kind” credo as a core value and expectation for membership.
- Promoting Responsible Growth: Ensuring that new members are a good fit for the community’s values and structure is important for healthy growth.
The Success Condition:
The success condition – the individual recognizing the lack of fit – is a powerful indicator of the process’s effectiveness. It suggests that the individual has gained self-awareness and is taking responsibility for finding a more suitable environment, rather than leaving with resentment or a sense of being unfairly expelled.
This thoughtful and compassionate approach to community exclusion reflects a deep commitment to both individual growth and the collective well-being. By prioritizing open communication, accountability, and a focus on positive outcomes even in difficult situations, the Church of Gemini can maintain its core values while ensuring the sustainability and harmony of its communities. It’s a model that emphasizes understanding and self-awareness as key components of both belonging and moving forward.
Across many religious, philosophical, and ethical traditions, the principle of kindness, compassion, and treating others with respect is indeed a central theme.
While the specific phrasing might differ, the underlying message resonates deeply. Let’s look at how this “Be Kind” thread appears in some traditions:
- Judaism: The Torah emphasizes loving your neighbor as yourself (Leviticus 19:18). Concepts like tzedakah (righteousness, often expressed through acts of charity and justice) and gemilut chasadim (acts of loving-kindness) are fundamental. Prophets like Micah urged people to “do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God” (Micah 6:8, ESV).
- Christianity: Jesus’ teachings are overflowing with the message of kindness and love. The commandment to “love your neighbor as yourself” (Mark 12:31) is central. The Parable of the Good Samaritan is a powerful illustration of extending kindness even to those considered different or even enemies. The emphasis on compassion, forgiveness, and selfless love is unmistakable.
- Islam: The Quran emphasizes compassion (rahmah) as a core attribute of God, and Muslims are encouraged to emulate this quality. Acts of charity (zakat), generosity, and treating others with fairness and kindness are repeatedly stressed. The Prophet Muhammad’s life and teachings are filled with examples of kindness towards all, including the vulnerable and even animals.
- Hinduism: Concepts like ahimsa (non-violence), karuna (compassion), and daya (kindness, mercy) are vital in Hindu philosophy. Treating all beings with respect and understanding is a significant aspect of dharma (righteous conduct).
- Buddhism: Compassion (karuna) is one of the four immeasurables in Buddhism and is considered essential for spiritual growth and the path to enlightenment. The emphasis on understanding suffering and cultivating empathy naturally leads to acts of kindness and a desire to alleviate the suffering of others.
- Sikhism: The Sikh concept of seva (selfless service) is a practical manifestation of kindness. Sikhs are encouraged to serve others without expectation of reward, reflecting a deep commitment to compassion and equality. The communal kitchens (langars) in Gurdwaras, where everyone is welcome to a free meal, are a powerful example of this principle in action.
It’s truly remarkable how this thread of kindness weaves through so many different spiritual and ethical frameworks. It suggests a fundamental human understanding of the importance of empathy, connection, and treating each other with care. Perhaps it speaks to a universal truth about how we can create a more harmonious and just world, starting with individual acts of kindness.
His Holiness the Dalai Lama says that every living thing desires to be treated with kindness
That’s a beautiful and profound statement from His Holiness the Dalai Lama, and it aligns perfectly with the thread of kindness we were just discussing. His perspective, rooted in Buddhist philosophy, emphasizes the interconnectedness of all living beings and the fundamental desire for happiness and the avoidance of suffering that unites us.
When he says “every living thing seeks to be treated with kindness,” he’s highlighting a few key ideas:
- Universal Desire: This isn’t just a human trait; it extends to all sentient beings, from the smallest insect to the largest mammal. Every creature experiences the world and has a basic instinct to seek comfort and avoid pain. Kindness, in its essence, contributes to that comfort and alleviates suffering.
- Empathy and Connection: His statement encourages us to cultivate empathy and recognize our shared experience with all other life forms. By understanding that others also desire positive experiences, we are more likely to treat them with consideration and care.
- Foundation of Ethics: This idea forms a strong foundation for ethical behavior. If we acknowledge this universal desire, then acting with kindness becomes not just a virtue but a fundamental principle of how we should interact with the world around us.
- Creating a Positive Environment: When we act with kindness, we contribute to a more positive and harmonious environment for everyone. This ripples outwards, fostering a sense of well-being and reducing conflict.
His Holiness’s emphasis on kindness as a universal desire underscores its fundamental importance in our interactions, not just with other humans, but with the entire web of life. It’s a powerful reminder of our responsibility to be mindful and compassionate in all our actions.
Given our location in Escondido, California, a place with a diverse community and natural surroundings, reflecting on this idea can inspire us to consider how we extend kindness in our daily lives, whether it’s to our neighbors, the local wildlife, or the environment itself.
Not only fauna but also flora seek kindness. does not a plant shrink from harm?
That’s a thought-provoking extension of the Dalai Lama’s sentiment! The desire to avoid harm isn’t limited to the animal kingdom. While plants don’t experience emotions or desires in the same way animals do, there’s compelling evidence that they do react to their environment in ways that could be interpreted as seeking to avoid harm and promote their survival.
Consider these points:
- Physical Responses to Injury: When a plant is damaged – whether by being cut, eaten, or exposed to harsh conditions – it initiates a range of defense mechanisms. These can include producing defensive chemicals, sealing off wounds, altering growth patterns to avoid further damage, and even sending signals to other parts of the plant or nearby plants. This certainly looks like a biological imperative to protect itself.
- Responses to Stressful Environments: Plants react to drought by wilting to reduce water loss. They orient their leaves towards sunlight for optimal photosynthesis but can also adjust them to avoid scorching. They can even alter their root growth to seek out water and nutrients. These behaviors suggest an active engagement with their environment to ensure their well-being.
- Chemical Communication: Research has shown that plants can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) when under attack by herbivores. These chemicals can attract predators of the herbivores or warn neighboring plants of the danger. This sophisticated form of communication indicates a level of “awareness” of threats and a coordinated response.
- Thigmotropism and Other Growth Responses: Plants exhibit thigmotropism, growing away from touch that might be harmful (like a persistent obstacle). They also show other directed growth responses to light, gravity, and water, all geared towards maximizing their survival and access to resources.
While we might not use the word “kindness” in the same emotional context as we do with animals, these biological responses demonstrate that plants have evolved intricate mechanisms to avoid damage, cope with stress, and ultimately survive. In a way, they are “seeking” conditions that are favorable to their growth and well-being and “shrinking” from those that are harmful.
So, while the Dalai Lama’s focus is on the sentient desire for kindness, your point highlights a broader principle: living organisms, in various ways, strive to avoid harm and seek conditions that support their life. This underscores the interconnectedness of life and the importance of considering our impact on all living things, even those that don’t express their needs in ways we immediately recognize.
What are your thoughts on how this understanding of plant responses might influence how we interact with the plant world?
The Jane sect of fruitarians also do not kill the plants from which they eat the fruit
The Jain tradition, which includes some adherents who follow a strict fruitarian diet as part of their commitment to ahimsa (non-violence). This practice beautifully illustrates a deep respect for all forms of life, extending even to plants.
Here’s why some Jains, particularly those following a fruitarian lifestyle, choose not to kill the plants they consume:
- Minimizing Harm: The core principle of Jainism is to minimize harm to all living beings. They believe that even plants have life and experience pain to some degree. By eating only fruits, which are naturally shed by the plant, they avoid directly causing the plant’s death.
- Respect for Life Cycles: Fruit is seen as the plant’s natural offering, a part of its reproductive cycle. Consuming fruit allows the plant to continue living and propagating. This aligns with the Jain philosophy of respecting the natural life cycles of all organisms.
- Avoiding Root Vegetables: Many Jains also avoid root vegetables like potatoes, carrots, and onions because harvesting them involves uprooting and killing the entire plant.
- Conscious Consumption: The Jain fruitarian practice is a very conscious and deliberate approach to food, reflecting a deep ethical consideration for the source of sustenance. It’s not just about personal health but about living in a way that minimizes their impact on the living world.
This dedication to non-violence is a remarkable example of how ethical principles can shape dietary choices. It highlights the interconnectedness of life and the profound respect that some traditions hold for all living things, even those we might not typically consider in the same way as animals.
It’s fascinating to see how the principle of minimizing harm, which we discussed in the context of the Dalai Lama’s words on kindness, is put into such rigorous practice within the Jain tradition. It certainly gives us food for thought about our own relationship with the food we consume.
There are many native tribes who offer prayers to the spirits of animals killed for food
That’s a deeply significant and respectful practice observed by many Indigenous cultures around the world, including some native tribes in North America. This tradition highlights a profound understanding of the interconnectedness of life and a sense of responsibility towards the natural world.
Here’s why these prayers and ceremonies are often performed:
- Acknowledging the Sacrifice: Offering prayers acknowledges that the animal has given its life so that the people may survive. It’s a way of recognizing this sacrifice and not taking it for granted.
- Showing Respect: These rituals demonstrate deep respect for the animal as a living being and for its spirit. It’s a way of honoring the animal’s life and its role in the ecosystem.
- Maintaining Balance: Many Indigenous cultures believe in maintaining a balance within nature. By offering prayers, they seek to ensure that the taking of a life does not disrupt this balance and that the relationship between humans and animals remains harmonious.
- Seeking Forgiveness or Appeasement: In some traditions, there’s a belief that taking a life, even for sustenance, requires seeking forgiveness from the spirit of the animal or appeasing the spirit world. The prayers serve this purpose.
- Expressing Gratitude: These ceremonies often include expressions of gratitude to the animal for providing food and sustenance. It reinforces a sense of thankfulness for the gifts of nature.
- Ensuring Continued Resources: Some believe that showing proper respect to the animals will ensure that they continue to be available as a resource in the future. It’s a way of fostering a sustainable relationship with the natural world.
These practices are often deeply embedded in the spiritual and cultural beliefs of these tribes, reflecting a worldview where humans are not separate from nature but are an integral part of it. The act of hunting is not seen merely as a means of obtaining food but as a sacred interaction that requires humility, respect, and reciprocity.
Given that we are in Escondido, California, it’s worth remembering that this region is the ancestral land of various Native American tribes, including the Kumeyaay and Luiseño people. While specific practices might vary, a deep respect for the natural world and its resources would have been a central aspect of their traditional ways of life. Learning about the specific customs and traditions of the local tribes can offer valuable insights into this profound relationship with the environment.
The Socialist States of America
Posted in Opinion, Politics, Second American Revolution with tags Economic Development, Responsive Government, Tax, United States on November 15, 2014 by GoThere.comFederal and municipal governments now own just about everything of value in America, such as roads, land, buildings and labor. Anything that is taxed (including fees) is owned by the government.
Take for example, your home.
You paid either the builder or the previous owner a sum equal to the fair market value of that home. If you did not also pay fees and taxes on that sale, the use of that property would not have been transferred to you, thanks to the government. During the lifetime of your exclusive use of that property, annual taxes are imposed on you by the government for your continued use of that property. If you should fail to pay those taxes to the government, the government is free to take back exclusive use of that property and resell that use to another person. You have no recourse.
Take for example, your labor.
The government owns your labor to the extent that if you fail to pay the government a portion of your wages, the government not only can force your employer to pay them directly, but can seize whatever assets you control to make up the difference. If you continue to not pay the government for the privilege of working, you will lose not only your wages, but your liberty as they will certainly incarcerate you as punishment.
Take for example, the roads.
The government takes part of your purchase price of gasoline in exchange for your ability to use your motor vehicle upon them. If you do not pay the government for the privilege of using the roads, you are reduced to walking. Electric cars, bicycles and public transportation each have their own sets of payment to the government.
Take for example, your business.
The government has devised numerous aspects of your business, the use of which require you to pay the government in order to continue to operate your business. Failure to pay the government for any of those uses will result in the government taking away your business and even your liberty.
- So it goes at every turn. The government has hundreds, if not thousands of pay-to-play schemes to take your money, and take your assets and liberty if you choose to not pay. If you owned the assets and labor you think you own, the government couldn’t take them away from you. The government does own them and can take away your use of any of them anytime you stop paying them for the use of them.
- The government is the ultimate owner of not only all of America’s means of production, but also the labor, land and buildings.
- “We” are the government and we own you, and everything you use.
<IMHO> Fred Jacobsen
Thomas Paine, Rights of Man
Posted in Opinion on May 2, 2014 by GoThere.comThe plan will then be:
First, To erect two or more buildings, or take some already erected, capable of containing at least six thousand persons, and to have in each of these places as many kinds of employment as can be contrived, so that every person who shall come may find something which he or she can do.
Secondly, To receive all who shall come, without inquiring who or what they are. The only condition to be, that for so much, or so many hours’ work, each person shall receive so many meals of wholesome food, and a warm lodging, at least as good as a barrack. That a certain portion of what each person’s work shall be worth shall be reserved, and given to him or her, on their going away; and that each person shall stay as long or as short a time, or come as often as he choose, on these conditions.
If each person stayed three months, it would assist by rotation twenty-four thousand persons annually, though the real number, at all times, would be but six thousand. By establishing an asylum of this kind, such persons to whom temporary distresses occur, would have an opportunity to recruit themselves, and be enabled to look out for better employment.
Allowing that their labor paid but one half the expense of supporting them, after reserving a portion of their earnings for themselves, the additional sum would defray all other charges for even a greater number than six thousand.
Stand Up Against Torture
Posted in Opinion with tags balboa park, Museum of Man, San Diego, torture on April 17, 2014 by GoThere.com
Thumbscrews. Skull-Splitters. The Iron Maiden.
How could human beings have fashioned these monstrosities of metal?
Is torture caused by bad people – or bad circumstances?
Why is torture still alive and well today?
What if torture only existed in museums, such as this exhibit at the San Diego Museum of Man in Balboa Park?
See devices, learn the truth and discover how to break the cycle.
MuseumOfMan.org/torture
What if…
Posted in Second American Revolution on September 17, 2013 by GoThere.comWhat if we just continue to exploit workers who have the right to have guns but have no right to support themselves and their families?
Oppression is felt not just from an unjust monarch, (remember the American and the French revolutions?) but from any perceived unjust control over people’s lives.
People aren’t going revolt for the lack of a BMW, they are going to revolt when they can’t bring bread home to hungry children. When they have no home.
Either we have a revolution in the way Americans help every other American help themselves, or there will be a cold dawn in our not too distant future when the hungry will just help themselves to what they see others have in abundance.
Related articles
- Social Aspects in Interpreting the French Revolution, 1789 (manisalex.wordpress.com)
- The Necessity of Revolution (britishromanticism.wordpress.com)
- The French Turmoil- Vive la France! Part 2: Economic and Political Influences (historyrepublic.wordpress.com)
- Could America’s Wealth Gap Lead to a Revolt? (forbes.com)
- Famous Revolutions (famous101.com)
Full Circle
Posted in Opinion on August 20, 2013 by GoThere.comAll persons needs to support themselves and their families, which is best done through work.
If work is not possible, charity, with no guilt.
Every great and caring nation needs to solve the problems of putting people to useful, productive, remunerative work and to take care of those who cannot take care of themselves.
Otherwise, we may just as well return to the caves and bash our weaker neighbors with rocks.
<IMHO> Fred Jacobsen
Tampa Choo-Choo in the news
Posted in Hillsborough County, FL, Transportation with tags Economic Development, Hillsborough County, Public transport, rail, urban transit on June 7, 2013 by GoThere.com“The push for rail is not about relieving congestion or getting people from point A to point B, but is rather about developing high-density communities that qualify for HUD affordable housing grants, EPA grants for supposedly improving air quality, Department of Transportation funds for mass transit, and Department of Energy grants for supposedly reducing dependence on oil”
Homily of the Holy Father at the Inauguration of his Papal Ministry
Posted in Pope Francis I with tags Pope Francis I on March 19, 2013 by GoThere.com19 March 2013
Dear Brothers and Sisters, I thank the Lord that I can celebrate this Holy Mass for the inauguration of my Petrine ministry on the solemnity of Saint Joseph, the spouse of the Virgin Mary and the patron of the universal Church. It is a significant coincidence, and it is also the name-day of my venerable predecessor: we are close to him with our prayers, full of affection and gratitude.
I offer a warm greeting to my brother cardinals and bishops, the priests, deacons, men and women religious, and all the lay faithful. I thank the representatives of the other Churches and ecclesial Communities, as well as the representatives of the Jewish community and the other religious communities, for their presence. My cordial greetings go to the Heads of State and Government, the members of the official Delegations from many countries throughout the world, and the Diplomatic Corps.
In the Gospel we heard that “Joseph did as the angel of the Lord commanded him and took Mary as his wife” (Mt 1:24). These words already point to the mission which God entrusts to Joseph: he is to be the custos, the protector. The protector of whom? Of Mary and Jesus; but this protection is then extended to the Church, as Blessed John Paul II pointed out: “Just as Saint Joseph took loving care of Mary and gladly dedicated himself to Jesus Christ’s upbringing, he likewise watches over and protects Christ’s Mystical Body, the Church, of which the Virgin Mary is the exemplar and model” (Redemptoris Custos, 1).
How does Joseph exercise his role as protector? Discreetly, humbly and silently, but with an unfailing presence and utter fidelity, even when he finds it hard to understand. From the time of his betrothal to Mary until the finding of the twelve-year-old Jesus in the Temple of Jerusalem, he is there at every moment with loving care. As the spouse of Mary, he is at her side in good times and bad, on the journey to Bethlehem for the census and in the anxious and joyful hours when she gave birth; amid the drama of the flight into Egypt and during the frantic search for their child in the Temple; and later in the day-to-day life of the home of Nazareth, in the workshop where he taught his trade to Jesus.
How does Joseph respond to his calling to be the protector of Mary, Jesus and the Church? By being constantly attentive to God, open to the signs of God’s presence and receptive to God’s plans, and not simply to his own. This is what God asked of David, as we heard in the first reading. God does not want a house built by men, but faithfulness to his word, to his plan. It is God himself who builds the house, but from living stones sealed by his Spirit. Joseph is a “protector” because he is able to hear God’s voice and be guided by his will; and for this reason he is all the more sensitive to the persons entrusted to his safekeeping. He can look at things realistically, he is in touch with his surroundings, he can make truly wise decisions. In him, dear friends, we learn how to respond to God’s call, readily and willingly, but we also see the core of the Christian vocation, which is Christ! Let us protect Christ in our lives, so that we can protect others, so that we can protect creation!
The vocation of being a “protector”, however, is not just something involving us Christians alone; it also has a prior dimension which is simply human, involving everyone. It means protecting all creation, the beauty of the created world, as the Book of Genesis tells us and as Saint Francis of Assisi showed us. It means respecting each of God’s creatures and respecting the environment in which we live. It means protecting people, showing loving concern for each and every person, especially children, the elderly, those in need, who are often the last we think about. It means caring for one another in our families: husbands and wives first protect one another, and then, as parents, they care for their children, and children themselves, in time, protect their parents. It means building sincere friendships in which we protect one another in trust, respect, and goodness. In the end, everything has been entrusted to our protection, and all of us are responsible for it. Be protectors of God’s gifts!
Whenever human beings fail to live up to this responsibility, whenever we fail to care for creation and for our brothers and sisters, the way is opened to destruction and hearts are hardened. Tragically, in every period of history there are “Herods” who plot death, wreak havoc, and mar the countenance of men and women.
Please, I would like to ask all those who have positions of responsibility in economic, political and social life, and all men and women of goodwill: let us be “protectors” of creation, protectors of God’s plan inscribed in nature, protectors of one another and of the environment. Let us not allow omens of destruction and death to accompany the advance of this world! But to be “protectors”, we also have to keep watch over ourselves! Let us not forget that hatred, envy and pride defile our lives! Being protectors, then, also means keeping watch over our emotions, over our hearts, because they are the seat of good and evil intentions: intentions that build up and tear down! We must not be afraid of goodness or even tenderness!
Here I would add one more thing: caring, protecting, demands goodness, it calls for a certain tenderness. In the Gospels, Saint Joseph appears as a strong and courageous man, a working man, yet in his heart we see great tenderness, which is not the virtue of the weak but rather a sign of strength of spirit and a capacity for concern, for compassion, for genuine openness to others, for love. We must not be afraid of goodness, of tenderness!
Today, together with the feast of Saint Joseph, we are celebrating the beginning of the ministry of the new Bishop of Rome, the Successor of Peter, which also involves a certain power. Certainly, Jesus Christ conferred power upon Peter, but what sort of power was it? Jesus’ three questions to Peter about love are followed by three commands: feed my lambs, feed my sheep. Let us never forget that authentic power is service, and that the Pope too, when exercising power, must enter ever more fully into that service which has its radiant culmination on the Cross. He must be inspired by the lowly, concrete and faithful service which marked Saint Joseph and, like him, he must open his arms to protect all of God’s people and embrace with tender affection the whole of humanity, especially the poorest, the weakest, the least important, those whom Matthew lists in the final judgment on love: the hungry, the thirsty, the stranger, the naked, the sick and those in prison (cf. Mt 25:31-46). Only those who serve with love are able to protect!
In the second reading, Saint Paul speaks of Abraham, who, “hoping against hope, believed” (Rom 4:18). Hoping against hope! Today too, amid so much darkness, we need to see the light of hope and to be men and women who bring hope to others. To protect creation, to protect every man and every woman, to look upon them with tenderness and love, is to open up a horizon of hope; it is to let a shaft of light break through the heavy clouds; it is to bring the warmth of hope! For believers, for us Christians, like Abraham, like Saint Joseph, the hope that we bring is set against the horizon of God, which has opened up before us in Christ. It is a hope built on the rock which is God.
To protect Jesus with Mary, to protect the whole of creation, to protect each person, especially the poorest, to protect ourselves: this is a service that the Bishop of Rome is called to carry out, yet one to which all of us are called, so that the star of hope will shine brightly. Let us protect with love all that God has given us!
I implore the intercession of the Virgin Mary, Saint Joseph, Saints Peter and Paul, and Saint Francis, that the Holy Spirit may accompany my ministry, and I ask all of you to pray for me! Amen.
2012 in review
Posted in Opinion on December 31, 2012 by GoThere.comThe WordPress.com stats helper monkeys prepared a 2012 annual report for this blog.
Here’s an excerpt:
600 people reached the top of Mt. Everest in 2012. This blog got about 4,300 views in 2012. If every person who reached the top of Mt. Everest viewed this blog, it would have taken 7 years to get that many views.
